Premier League Most Penalties Scored [Top 12 Players]

There’s nothing most of us love than spending a Saturday afternoon taking in the Premier League in all its glory. Sure, we get an occasional Burnley Long Ball™, or Mourinho parks the bus before kick-off. 

But most of the time we get fast-paced action and plenty of drama – and there’s no better drama than penalties. Why was it given? Was it even a pen? 

Did the penalty taker sky it into orbit like a true defender a la John Terry in the Champions League?

That begs the question, with everything on the line, who would you want on the spot?

Most Premier League Penalties Scored [Top 12] 

Frank Lampard32782.1%
Steven Gerrard29780.1%
Harry Kane28487.5%
Mark Noble28584.9%
Sergio Agüero27681.8%
Jamie Vardy26583.9%
Wayne Rooney231069.7%
Luka Milivojevic22386.4%
Leighton Baines20290.9%
Troy Deeney18481.8%
Mohamed Salah18290.0%
Last Updated 8 September 2022

Most Successful Penalty Takers in Premier League 

Among the top 12 penalty scorers in Premier League fixtures, Leighton Baines (90.9%) Mohamed Salah (90.0%) and Harry Kane (87.5%) have the highest conversion rates in the league. The highest conversion rates in Premier League history are held by Yaya Touré (100% – 11 goals), Matt Le Tissier (96.2% – 25 out of 26), and Danny Murphy (94.7% – 18 out of 19).

The likes of Harry Kane and Mohammed Salah can continue to rise up the all-time penalties scored list. But when it comes to cracking the top 3 of all-time penalties conversion rate, they have their work cut out for them. 

To catch Danny Murphy at 94.7% Sir Harry will need to score his next 29 penalties. Salah will need to convert his next 18 pens to catch the former Fulham FC captain. 

Who Has Never Missed a Penalty in the Premier League?

There are dozens of players who have never missed a penalty in the Premier League. This is because there are several who are very early in their playing career or rarely take a penalty for their club. Yaya Toure is the only player to take more than 10 pens and score them all, going a perfect 11 for 11. 

Following behind Toure in the 100% club are Dimitar Berbatov (9), Rickie Lambert (7), and Jan Molby (7). Perhaps one day, a new up and coming star will catch Yaya’s perfect record; however, it seems unlikely to happen.

Outside of the Prem, plenty of players have never missed a penalty and made far more than 11. 

Worst Premier League Penalty Records 

During his time in the Premier League, Colombian Striker Juan Pablo Angel scored just 5 out of 10 penalties attempted. His conversion rate of 50% ranks him as the worst penalty taker in the league. Formerly of Tottenham and Sunderland, Steed Malbranque only managed one better than Angel, going 6 for 10.

With 33 attempts and 10 misses, Wayne Rooney is arguably the worst penalty taker in Premier League history. His conversion rate of 69.7% is more than 10 percentage points lower than any other player in the top 12 for penalties scored.

It must be something about playing in Premier League matches, as he’s actually 48 for 60 in all competitions–that’s a respectable penalty conversion rate of 80%!

Share this story

Rich Wolfenden Reveals What It's REALLY Like to be a Football Commentator👇

Kendon Carrera

Kendon Carrera eats sports for breakfast. As a long-suffering Utah Jazz and Fulham FC supporter, he numbs the pain of perpetual failure with many hobbies, though a master of none. Gaining respite through playing jazz guitar, brewing beer or drinking whisky. Follow Kendon on Instagram here

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts